The tragic drowning of a 16-year-old boy at a Christian holiday camp in Zimbabwe has stirred controversy and raised serious questions regarding the Church of England’s accountability. Edith Nyachuru, the boy’s sister, attributes her brother Guide Nyachuru’s death to the church’s failure to act against John Smyth, a notorious child abuser who oversaw the camp.
“The Church knew about the abuses that John Smyth was doing. They should have stopped him. Had they stopped him, I think my brother would still be alive,” Edith commented in an interview.
John Smyth, who relocated to Zimbabwe in 1984 with his family after facing allegations of severe abuse in the UK, established himself as a prominent figure within the local Christian community. Just two years prior, a report by Anglican clergyman Mark Ruston had detailed horrific accounts of physical and sexual abuse he inflicted on boys at camps he ran in Britain.
Despite these past transgressions, Smyth continued his abusive practices at Zambesi Ministries in Zimbabwe, where he employed similar disciplinary methods under the guise of spiritual guidance. Witnesses report that Smyth encouraged nudity among campers and often exhibited inappropriate behavior himself.
Guide Nyachuru was reportedly excited about attending the camp as it was a gift from his sister. Sadly, within twelve hours of arriving at Ruzawi School on December 15, 1992, his family received devastating news: he had drowned after swimming naked—a tradition among the campers—while his absence went unnoticed by staff.
Following Guide’s death, confusion reigned as family members were denied access to view his body due to concerns about modesty. The investigations into Smyth’s practices were complicated by his legal expertise and connections within both church and government circles.
David Coltart, a lawyer who later investigated Smyth’s activities, uncovered alarming patterns of abuse. Despite compiling a report outlining these issues, which included recommendations to halt Smyth’s camps, accountability was slow to materialize.
Edith Nyachuru received a formal apology from Archbishop Justin Welby in 2021 acknowledging the church’s failures related to her brother’s death. However, she described this gesture as insufficient and is now calling for greater accountability from church leaders who ignored warning signs.
Looking ahead, Coltart emphasizes that it is not solely the Church’s responsibility but also institutions in the UK to address their past failures regarding Smyth. He advocates for outreach efforts to locate potential victims still suffering from trauma today.
As investigations continue and more victims come forward, it remains crucial for both church officials and legal authorities to prioritize accountability and support for healing among those affected by such abuses in faith-based settings.
Grieving Family Blames Church for Drowning Tragedy The tragic drowning of a 16-year-old boy at a Christian holiday camp in Zimbabwe has sparked outrage and prompted his family to hold the Church of England accountable.
Trump’s Tariff Plans: A Day-One Agenda Against Drug and Human Trafficking In a bold move to combat drug and human smuggling, President-elect Donald Trump has announced plans to impose significant tariffs on Mexico, Canada, and China immediately after his inauguration on January 20.