The tragic drowning of a 16-year-old boy at a Christian holiday camp in Zimbabwe has sparked outrage and prompted his family to hold the Church of England accountable. Guide Nyachuru drowned while swimming, and his sister, Edith Nyachuru, believes that had the church taken action against known abuser John Smyth, her brother might still be alive. This incident raises critical questions about accountability within religious organizations.
John Smyth, a British barrister who moved to Zimbabwe in 1984, previously faced serious allegations of abuse in the UK. A 1982 report by Anglican clergyman Mark Ruston detailed horrific accounts of physical and psychological abuse at camps he operated, yet the findings went largely unaddressed. Despite these revelations, Smyth re-established himself as a respected figure within the Zimbabwean Christian community, leading Zambesi Ministries and conducting camps that drew children from elite schools.
Edith Nyachuru recalled that her brother’s trip to the camp was meant to be a festive gift from a sibling. Tragically, within just 12 hours of his arrival, the family received devastating news of his death.
Witnesses indicated that swimming naked was a camp tradition. Guide’s absence went unnoticed until his body was discovered at the bottom of the pool the next morning. His family faced further trauma when they were denied access to view his body due to him being “indecently dressed.”
Smyth’s behavior at these camps raised significant alarm. Attendees reported that he often appeared naked in communal spaces and encouraged similar behavior among boys under his care. He further engaged in inappropriate activities disguised as “fun,” which included discussions on masturbation and promoting nudity.
Concerns about Smyth’s conduct led to an investigation by lawyer David Coltart, who uncovered troubling practices involving corporal punishment using a wooden paddle referred to as “TTB.”
Coltart’s findings prompted action against Smyth; however, legal proceedings faced numerous obstacles, including missing documents and Smyth’s formidable legal expertise. The eventual report detailing Smyth’s abuses was not widely circulated due to fears of defamation lawsuits but effectively curtailed his operations in Zimbabwe.
Despite facing legal charges for culpable homicide connected to Guide’s death, justice remained elusive. Smyth continued to evade serious repercussions until his death in 2018.
The Nyachuru family continues to seek accountability from church leaders who failed to act on known abuses. They express frustration over delayed apologies from church officials and call for systemic changes within religious institutions to prevent future tragedies.
Coltart emphasizes that accountability extends beyond the Church of England; it is imperative for institutions in both the UK and Zimbabwe to acknowledge their roles in protecting abusers like Smyth. As investigations continue, there is hope that victims will receive necessary support and acknowledgment of their suffering.
The tragic case serves as a stark reminder of the need for vigilance against abuse within trusted communities and emphasizes the importance of transparency and accountability in safeguarding vulnerable individuals.
Sister Blames Church for Brother’s Drowning at Zimbabwe Camp The tragic drowning of a 16-year-old boy at a Christian holiday camp in Zimbabwe has stirred controversy and raised serious questions regarding the Church of England’s accountability.
A Mother’s Heartbreak: The Tragic Impact of Knife Crime A mother’s life was irreversibly changed on what should have been a joyous Mother’s Day.